Home Physics Units, Dimensions and Measurement Mix Using dimensional analysis find the dependen…
Physics Units, Dimensions and Measurement Mix MCQ (Single Correct)

Using dimensional analysis find the dependency of the time for the sand to run down through, following egg timer, on the diameter ‘d’ of the aperture.

Share this question

For Instagram sharing, use “Apps” on mobile or copy the link.

Text Solution

Verified by Experts
The correct answer is:
CHECK THE SOLUTION

Sol. (T ~ i.e., T ∝ d –5/2 )

The sand flows through the aperature almost uniformly, and therefore the total operating time T of the sand-glass is proportional to the volume H 3 of the sand. (As our aim is to obtain only a rough estimate, the difference between the volumes of a cone and a cube is ignored). The time T may also depend on the gravitational acceleration g, the diameter d of the aperture and density ρ of the sand, and so T ≈ H 3 × f (g,d, ρ ).

As T is a time and only g contains a time dimension, the function f has to be proportional to the reciprocal of the square root of g. Similar reasoning shows that T cannot depend on ρ , but is proportional to d –5/2 ; in summary, T ≈ H 3 / . The coefficient of proportionality is a dimensionless number, and since it does not depend on anything, can be assumed to be of order 1 (through such assumptions are notoriously dangerous in some branches of physics !). Consider some realistic data. If, for example, H is a few centimeters and d is around a millimeter, T is a few minutes, which is indeed the sort of time for which an egg should be boiled.

Prepare Smarter with CGP Edu

Get practice questions, solutions, and test series in one place.

Write a Review

Share your experience with this question and solution.

Commentary

Send your comment, doubt, correction, or feedback to admin.

Student Reviews

What students say about this solution

No reviews yet. Be the first to write a review.

Similar Questions

Explore conceptually related problems

CG
CGP Question Assistant Question Bank + AI Help
Hi! Type your question or upload one screenshot. First I will search related questions from CGP Edu Question Bank. If none match, type YES and I will solve it with AI.
Upload only one screenshot at a time. Flow: Question Bank first → If not matched, type YES for AI solution.